HomeConsumer + MoneyConsumerCellphonesChoosing a phone and phone plan

Choosing a phone and phone plan

Woman holding cellphone

Choosing a cellphone and plan can be a complicated process. Two-year contract or pay-as-you-go? Smartphone or basic flip phone? Individual or shared plan? It’s certainly tricky. Let’s dive in.

What you should know

The phone and the plan have very different pricing structures. Sometimes a new phone comes with the plan, sometimes it doesn’t.

Many people sign a service contract with a telecom provider. But that’s not your only option. And it’s rarely your cheapest.

There are three broad options for a phone plan:

  • long-term contract
  • month-to-month
  • prepaid

Let's unpack each option.

Most people who buy a new phone also sign a contract with a service provider. That way the phone is “free” (or heavily discounted).

In the contract, you agree to make a minimum monthly payment for the term of the contract, typically two years. You get a set amount of minutes, texts, and data. If you go over, you have to pay extra.

Here’s the key difference between a contract and a month-to-month plan: if you end a contract early, you have to pay a penalty.

And that "free" phone is not actually free — the cost is built into the contract payments. You end up paying the full cost of that fancy iPhone over the length of the contract.

With month-to-month plans, you don’t have to commit to a long-term service contract. But you also don’t get a new phone in the deal. Your “old” phone will have to do.

Once your initial cellphone contract runs out, your phone is paid off too. Now you have bargaining power. Ask your current provider: “What’s your best price for a month-to-month service?” And be sure to shop around!

Prepaid services are bought in advance — for example, a prepaid card or pay-as-you-go. Typically, you’ll bring your own phone to this plan.

With prepaid services, you put money into an account. Every time you make a call, send a text or use data, the cost is taken off your balance. When your balance runs out, you buy more credit, “topping up” your account.

Prepaid services are typically less expensive than long-term contracts. You only pay for what you use. There’s no risk of “bill shock” — getting a bill that’s much higher than expected.

But not all pre-paid service is created equal. Some plans allow you to continue using the service even if your account balance is at $0. But you’ll have to pay, and it might be at a different (hint: more expensive) rate than your current plan. There also may be interest charges added if you take too long to pay.

Ask questions when signing up for a prepaid plan. Find out what happens if you go over your balance. You should know how to:

  • check your usage balance
  • contact the provider’s customer service department
  • complain about the service

If you get a new phone in the deal, you should be told about:

  • any early cancellation fees, how much they decrease each month, and when you’re free from them
  • the retail price of the phone and the amount you paid
  • where you can find information about device upgrades and the manufacturer’s warranty

Protect yourself!

Think you’re ready to sign up for phone service? Check out these key questions you should ask before agreeing to anything.

  • If a phone handset is provided, what’s the price for the phone alone?

  • Can I upgrade my phone, and how would that affect my plan?

  • What’s covered under the extended warranty, and how much does it cost?

A couple more:

  • What happens if the phone has a problem? Will you repair it, replace it, or return my money?

  • Where do I have to take the phone for repairs?

And some key questions to ask about the plan.

  • What’s the minimum actual amount I’ll have to pay each month (including any add-on fees and taxes)?

  • Do you have coverage where I live, work and travel? (Global coverage maps are available online; check out Opensignal.)

  • How many texts, local calling minutes, and GBs (gigabytes) of data are included?

  • If I exceed my limits, particularly for data, what extra charges apply?

A few more:

  • Are national or international calls included?

  • How much will I have to pay to make calls or use the internet if I visit another country?

  • Can I decide to go onto a higher or lower plan if I want to, without penalty?

  • Exactly how much will I have to pay to cancel the contract or commitment?

  • This information applies to British Columbia, Canada
  • Reviewed for legal accuracy in January 2020
  • Time to read: 3 minutes

Reviewed for legal accuracy by

Dean Davison, Davison North Law

Dean Davison, Davison North Law

Share this page

This information from People’s Law School explains in a general way the law that applies in British Columbia, Canada. The information is not intended as legal advice. See our disclaimer.


On Dial-A-Law

Dial-A-Law has more information on Cellphones in the section on Consumer.

Copyright 2022 People's Law School

We are grateful to work on the unceded traditional territories of the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam), Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish) and səlilwətaɬ (Tsleil-Waututh) Nations, whose Peoples continue to live on and care for these lands.